Login
List your B&B
B&B Shelter Island
99 Bed and Breakfasts in and around Shelter Island,
New York
,
United States
Filter
Sort
Our top selection
Price: Low → High
Price: High → Low
Best rated
Map
Review score
General amenities
Free Wifi
Electric vehicle charging station
Garden
Pets allowed
Free parking
More
Room Amenities
Private bathroom
Private entrance
Air conditioning
Bath
Private terrace
Private kitchen
More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible
Entire unit located on ground floor
Upper floors accessible by elevator
More
Room type
Holiday home
Guest room
Apartment
Accommodations just outside your destination
Near Shelter Island
Modern Hampton Bays Home with Outdoor Pool!
Hampton Bays
8
(27.7 km from Shelter Island)
The Old Lyme Inn
Old Lyme
9
(28.5 km from Shelter Island)
Charming Niantic Vacation Rental Walk to Beach!
Niantic
9
(28.9 km from Shelter Island)
Coastal Getaway with Porch, 2 Mi to Niantic Beach!
Niantic
10
(29.4 km from Shelter Island)
Hampton Bays Retreat Walk to Squires Beach!
Hampton Bays
8
(29.4 km from Shelter Island)
Luxurious Hamptons House with Heated Pool & Grill
Hampton Bays
10
(29.6 km from Shelter Island)
1860's Colonial House Near Downtown and Beaches!
Madison
10
(29.6 km from Shelter Island)
Newly Renovated Carriage House Near Town & Beaches
Madison
10
(29.7 km from Shelter Island)
Hamptons Getaway
East Quogue
10
(30.3 km from Shelter Island)
Coastal Waterford Getaway, Steps to the Water!
Waterford
10
(31.6 km from Shelter Island)
Scranton Seahorse Inn
Madison
9.1
(31.7 km from Shelter Island)
Niantic Duplex with Deck Less Than 1 Mi to Beach and Boardwalk
Niantic
9
(31.7 km from Shelter Island)
The Griswold Inn
Essex
8.6
(31.7 km from Shelter Island)
Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps to River!
Essex
10
(31.8 km from Shelter Island)
Copper Beech Inn
Ivoryton
8.2
(31.9 km from Shelter Island)
Historic Essex Home with Large Yard Near Downtown!
Essex
8.6
(32.1 km from Shelter Island)
The Homestead
Madison
9.6
(33 km from Shelter Island)
A Wave Inn - Montauk
Montauk
8.1
(33.2 km from Shelter Island)
Townhouses & Captain's Quarters
Montauk
9
(33.5 km from Shelter Island)
Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
Montauk
8.6
(33.5 km from Shelter Island)
North Harbor Montauk
Montauk
8.7
(33.5 km from Shelter Island)
Shore Drive - 2 Bedroom/2 Bath/Bunk/Queen Oasis
Waterford
7
(33.6 km from Shelter Island)
Remodeled Farmhouse in Waterford Near 2 Beaches!
Waterford
10
(34.8 km from Shelter Island)
Don't Ditch Your Plains
Montauk
8
(35.4 km from Shelter Island)
Load next page
1
2
3
4
5