Login
List your B&B
B&B Shelter Island
97 Bed and Breakfasts in and around Shelter Island,
New York
,
United States
Filter
Sort
Our top selection
Price: Low → High
Price: High → Low
Best rated
Map
Room type
Holiday home
Guest room
Apartment
Review score
General amenities
Free Wifi
Garden
Pets allowed
Free parking
More
Room Amenities
Private bathroom
Private entrance
Air conditioning
Bath
Private terrace
Private kitchen
More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible
Entire unit located on ground floor
Upper floors accessible by elevator
More
Accommodations just outside your destination
Near Shelter Island
Charming Old Lyme Cottage, Steps to Private Beach!
Old Lyme
7.9
(24.8 km from Shelter Island)
Shorewood Inn
Jamesport
7.9
(24.9 km from Shelter Island)
Cozy Westbrook Vacation Rental - Walk to Beach!
Westbrook
9
(25.2 km from Shelter Island)
Hamptons Vacation Rental with Seasonal Pool!
Hampton Bays
8.5
(25.3 km from Shelter Island)
White Sands Motel
Amagansett
8.8
(25.3 km from Shelter Island)
Hampton Bays 4bdr all Q size,IG Pool,Billiard, tennis
Hampton Bays
10
(25.6 km from Shelter Island)
Hamptons Retreat: Near Beaches, Restaurants, Wineries
Hampton Bays
10
(25.7 km from Shelter Island)
The Captain Stannard
Westbrook
9.4
(25.8 km from Shelter Island)
Westbrook Inn Bed and Breakfast
Westbrook
9.1
(25.8 km from Shelter Island)
Unit 1925 Ocean Colony Beach
Amagansett
7
(26 km from Shelter Island)
Unit 1911 Ocean Colony Beach
Amagansett
10
(26 km from Shelter Island)
Unit 1721 Ocean Colony Beach
Amagansett
8
(26 km from Shelter Island)
Unit 1724 Ocean Colony Beach
Amagansett
8
(26 km from Shelter Island)
Hamptons Bay Home on Shinnecock Bay with Yard!
Hampton Bays
7
(26.9 km from Shelter Island)
Charming Hampton Bays Home 5 Mi to Coopers Beach
Hampton Bays
7.3
(27 km from Shelter Island)
Premier Waterfront Cottage 2
Riverhead
10
(27.1 km from Shelter Island)
Premier Waterfront Cottage 3
Riverhead
10
(27.1 km from Shelter Island)
Waterfront Cottage 4
Riverhead
10
(27.1 km from Shelter Island)
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
Old Saybrook
7.6
(27.3 km from Shelter Island)
Clinton Motel
Clinton
8
(27.3 km from Shelter Island)
Distinctive Hamptons Home with Pool Near Bay, Ocean
Hampton Bays
8
(27.5 km from Shelter Island)
Private beach on a fenced in property sunset views
Hampton Bays
10
(28.1 km from Shelter Island)
The Old Lyme Inn
Old Lyme
8.5
(28.5 km from Shelter Island)
Charming Niantic Vacation Rental Walk to Beach!
Niantic
9
(28.9 km from Shelter Island)
Load next page
1
2
3
4
5
