Manage your B&B

B&B Shelter Island

2 Bed and Breakfasts in Shelter Island City (New York, United States)

Our top selectionPrice: Low → HighPrice: High → LowBest rated

Accommodation type

Holiday home

Apartment

Bed & breakfast

Luxury home

Inn

Small-scale hotel

Review score

General amenities

Free Wifi

Electric vehicle charging station

Garden

Pets allowed

Free parking

Sauna

More

Room Amenities

Private bathroom

Family room

Private entrance

Air conditioning

Bath

Private terrace

More

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible

Entire unit located on ground floor

Upper floors accessible by elevator

Adults only

Accommodations just outside your destination

Near Shelter Island

The Griswold Inn - B&B Essex

The Griswold Inn - B&B Essex

The Griswold Inn

Direct reservation

(31.7 km from Shelter Island)

Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps to River! - B&B Essex

Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps to River! - B&B Essex

Downtown Essex Apartment - Steps to River!

Direct reservation

(31.8 km from Shelter Island)

Historic Essex Home w/ Large Yard Near Downtown! - B&B Essex

Historic Essex Home w/ Large Yard Near Downtown! - B&B Essex

Historic Essex Home w/ Large Yard Near Downtown!

Direct reservation

(32.1 km from Shelter Island)

The Homestead - B&B Madison

The Homestead - B&B Madison

Direct reservation

(33 km from Shelter Island)

Lucky 8 Camp Cozy Coastal Retreat with Hidey Hole & Family Charm - B&B Waterford

Lucky 8 Camp Cozy Coastal Retreat with Hidey Hole & Family Charm - B&B Waterford

Lucky 8 Camp Cozy Coastal Retreat with Hidey Hole & Family Charm

Direct reservation

(33.1 km from Shelter Island)

Harbor View - Newly Renovated - B&B Montauk

Harbor View - Newly Renovated - B&B Montauk

Harbor View - Newly Renovated

Direct reservation

(33.1 km from Shelter Island)

Clinton's Hidden Secret, a Distillerie until 1926 - B&B Clinton

Clinton's Hidden Secret, a Distillerie until 1926 - B&B Clinton

Clinton's Hidden Secret, a Distillerie until 1926

Direct reservation

(33.2 km from Shelter Island)

Townhouses & Captain's Quarters - B&B Montauk

Townhouses & Captain's Quarters - B&B Montauk

Townhouses & Captain's Quarters

Direct reservation

(33.5 km from Shelter Island)

Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort - Montauk - B&B Montauk

Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort - Montauk - B&B Montauk

Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort - Montauk

Direct reservation

(33.5 km from Shelter Island)

North Harbor Montauk - B&B Montauk

North Harbor Montauk - B&B Montauk

North Harbor Montauk

Direct reservation

(33.5 km from Shelter Island)

Dockside 2BR - Prime Location on the Marina Unit B - B&B Montauk

Dockside 2BR - Prime Location on the Marina Unit B - B&B Montauk

Dockside 2BR - Prime Location on the Marina Unit B

Direct reservation

(33.6 km from Shelter Island)

Inn at Ocean Avenue - B&B New London

Inn at Ocean Avenue - B&B New London

Inn at Ocean Avenue

Direct reservation

(34.3 km from Shelter Island)

Spacious Oceanview Villa Elegant Coastal Escape, Sleeps 22 - B&B New London

Spacious Oceanview Villa Elegant Coastal Escape, Sleeps 22 - B&B New London

Spacious Oceanview Villa Elegant Coastal Escape, Sleeps 22

Direct reservation

(35.1 km from Shelter Island)

Easy Beach Access! New London Apt w/ Kitchenette - B&B New London

Easy Beach Access! New London Apt w/ Kitchenette - B&B New London

Easy Beach Access! New London Apt w/ Kitchenette

Direct reservation

(35.3 km from Shelter Island)

Cozy Garden Apartment Along the Shoreline - B&B Guilford

Cozy Garden Apartment Along the Shoreline - B&B Guilford

Cozy Garden Apartment Along the Shoreline

Direct reservation

(35.7 km from Shelter Island)

New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots! - B&B New London

New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots! - B&B New London

New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots!

Direct reservation

(36.1 km from Shelter Island)

Walk to Eastern Point Beach: Apt w/ Water View! - B&B Groton

Walk to Eastern Point Beach: Apt w/ Water View! - B&B Groton

Walk to Eastern Point Beach: Apt w/ Water View!

Direct reservation

(36.3 km from Shelter Island)

New cozy coastal retreat! - B&B Groton

New cozy coastal retreat! - B&B Groton

New cozy coastal retreat!

Direct reservation

(36.7 km from Shelter Island)

Cozy Coastal Cottage - B&B New London

Cozy Coastal Cottage - B&B New London

Cozy Coastal Cottage

Direct reservation

(37.3 km from Shelter Island)

Tennis & Sea Escape - Hydrangeas in the Hamptons - B&B Westhampton Beach

Tennis & Sea Escape - Hydrangeas in the Hamptons - B&B Westhampton Beach

Tennis & Sea Escape - Hydrangeas in the Hamptons

Westhampton Beach

Direct reservation

(37.5 km from Shelter Island)

King-bed room with private bath -FREE WIFI-- New London-Mystic - B&B New London

King-bed room with private bath -FREE WIFI-- New London-Mystic - B&B New London

King-bed room with private bath -FREE WIFI-- New London-Mystic

Direct reservation

(38 km from Shelter Island)

Chic Groton Studio • A Cozy, Modern & Central Gem - B&B Groton

Chic Groton Studio • A Cozy, Modern & Central Gem - B&B Groton

Chic Groton Studio • A Cozy, Modern & Central Gem

Direct reservation

(38 km from Shelter Island)

Stylish 2BR Groton Getaway Close to Everything! - B&B Groton

Stylish 2BR Groton Getaway Close to Everything! - B&B Groton

Stylish 2BR Groton Getaway Close to Everything!

Direct reservation

(38 km from Shelter Island)

The Millhouse Downtown Chester - B&B Chester

The Millhouse Downtown Chester - B&B Chester

The Millhouse Downtown Chester

Direct reservation

(38.4 km from Shelter Island)

Discover unique B&B destinations

Subscribe to our newsletter

United States
New York
Shelter Island

Bedandbreakfast.eu

Service & Contact
About us
Travel inspiration

B&B hosts

Manage your B&B
List your B&B
Starting a B&B
FAQ
Must reads for B&B Innkeepers

Popular Destinations

Bed & Breakfast Edinburgh
Bed & Breakfast Dublin
Bed & Breakfast London
Bed & Breakfast Paris

English

Deutsch Español Français Italiano Nederlands

© 2026 Bedandbreakfast.eu